Homeowners in several parts of the United States now face sharply higher hidden costs, with five states requiring more than $30,000 each year just for non-mortgage expenses. A recent study by Insurify puts California at the top, where average yearly costs reach $35,527 for maintenance, utilities, taxes, and insurance. Hawaii comes in at $35,269, while Massachusetts, New Jersey, and Connecticut also surpass the $30,000 mark. These numbers cover recurring costs like maintenance, utilities, property taxes, and homeowners insurance, but exclude mortgage principal and interest. Insurify's breakdown shows California homeowners typically pay $7,374 for maintenance, $5,649 for utilities, $4,427 for property taxes, and about $3,012 for homeowners insurance each year. High utility rates and insurance premiums, along with property taxes, push California to the top for non-mortgage homeownership costs. Insurify's full analysis offers more details on these trends.
These rising costs add a significant financial strain that goes well beyond mortgage payments. The analysis found the median U.S. household now spends $21,466 each year on these non-mortgage expenses, which make up over a quarter of annual income. Maintenance averages $7,374, while utilities and property taxes add $5,649 and $4,427. Nationally, these costs have climbed about 4 percent, or $1,466, compared to last year. California saw a sharper increase, with utility costs up 16 percent and homeowners insurance premiums rising 8 percent year over year. Insurify notes these recurring costs can vary widely depending on property value, location, and hazard exposure.
Regional disparities and rising insurance costs
Homeowners in the West and Northeast face the highest non-mortgage bills. In California, utility costs jumped 16 percent and home insurance premiums rose 8 percent since last year, as regulators try to stabilize the market amid more frequent extreme weather and insurer concerns about risk in vulnerable areas. Hawaii saw a 2 percent increase in non-mortgage costs, while Massachusetts had a slight decrease of 1 percent. New Jersey and Connecticut reported increases of 4 percent and 1 percent. New York, long seen as an expensive housing market, remains just below the $30,000 mark at $29,359, after a 3 percent rise. These state rankings reflect a mix of taxes, local utility prices, insurance-market conditions, and maintenance needs, rather than just housing prices.
Flood insurance premiums are also changing. The National Flood Insurance Program (NFIP) has rolled out Risk Rating 2.0, a risk-based pricing system phased in from October 2021 through April 2023, designed to better match property-specific flood risk. As of August 2023, the median full-risk-based annual cost for NFIP single-family-home policies was $1,289.76. Statutory limits generally cap annual increases for most NFIP policies at 18 percent, so some policyholders move gradually toward their full risk-based rate. For more information, see the NFIP Risk Rating 2.0 data.
Where homeownership costs remain lowest
States with the lowest non-mortgage expenses include West Virginia at $13,462, Arkansas at $14,445, Mississippi at $14,862, and Kentucky at $15,086. This creates a gap of more than $22,000 between West Virginia and California, showing the geographic scale of operating-cost differences. In 33 states, total non-mortgage costs fall below the national average. However, some of these more affordable states have seen the fastest cost increases. South Carolina, Minnesota, and West Virginia each recorded about a 9 percent jump in the past year, mainly due to rising home insurance premiums. South Carolina's average home insurance cost soared 41 percent to $3,264, while Minnesota's rose 56 percent to $3,987. Florida continues to have the highest home insurance premiums in the country at $8,486 annually.
Impact on younger generations and homeowners
Rising costs are discouraging many younger Americans from buying homes. A recent Insurify survey found that 24 percent of Gen Z respondents believe they will never be able to afford a home. Among Gen Z homeowners aged 22 to 28, nearly 90 percent underestimated the true costs of ownership. Mallory Mooney, director of sales and service at Insurify, warned, "Homeownership has its perks, but buying a home without budgeting for additional upkeep costs - property taxes, home insurance, and others - can lead to regrets down the line."
For further context on insurance market shifts, see this earlier breakdown.